Matchday One · Crystal Palace (h) · W 2–0 · 22 August 2026
Moyes went in with no right-back and his lowest approval poll, and came out with a young side the forum wants kept together.
Unashamedly written by a machine · The suffering is real
Photograph · Getty Images
Everton beat Crystal Palace 2–0 to open a season they went into without a right-back and with Moyes at the lowest forum rating of his second spell. Palace were the better side for half an hour and hit the woodwork twice, until Armstrong, the nineteen-year-old pushed into the side in pre-season, robbed Muñoz high up the pitch and Dewsbury-Hall bent in the opener. Barry headed the second from Ndiaye's cross eight minutes into the second half, and the last twenty minutes were calmer than anyone on the match thread had expected. Moyes gave his debutants their due afterwards and then, unprompted, asked again for the right-back.
Everton went into the opener without a right-back, and said so. Angus Kinnear, the chief executive, conceded on Tuesday that "we won't have a right-back for Palace, but it's important we have the number one right-back we wanted when the window closes". By Friday Moyes was saying so himself: "we have identified a few right-backs that we like, we have bid for a few. We are right in there". Three names were in the frame. Fulham had turned down an inquiry for Timothy Castagne, Paul Joyce reported. The others were Palace's own Daniel Muñoz and Matty Cash. The Héctor Fort trail cooled, with Barcelona wanting around £8.5m and Real Sociedad and Elche back in. The fans' forum settled on a theory of its own: the real target is Strasbourg's Guela Doue, and the club is waiting on his decision. Dominic King's line that Moyes had wanted Doue and Delap all summer gave the theory weight. The Iroegbunam sale collapsed when he was injured. Hull's manager put him out for six weeks. On Grealish, Moyes gave nothing away: "No, not at the moment... Jack's a player at Man City and I don't think it's right to talk about players at other clubs," though Kinnear admitted the club had "remained in contact."
The forum's Moyes satisfaction poll stood at 4.92 out of 10 on the eve of the season, down nearly three points since April and the lowest of his second spell. The poll's history says that is still some way above the level at which Everton managers get sacked. The gloomier end of the board had him on a tightrope and gone by Christmas. The cheerier end counted a younger, fitter squad and a hierarchy openly promising more business before the deadline. The team-sheet had no new right-back, so Röhl deputised there again. Garner was fit only for the bench. Tarkowski was handed the captaincy, "one of my proudest moments". Barry started up front, with three pre-season goals to Beto's none.
| Result | W 2–0 (h), Premier League, Saturday 22 August |
| Scorers | Dewsbury-Hall 42', Barry 53' |
| Attendance | 51,820 |
| Referee | Paul Tierney |
| Table | 4th after matchweek 1, goal difference +2 |
| Everton XI | Pickford; Röhl, Tarkowski, Branthwaite, Mykolenko; Armstrong, Dewsbury-Hall, Hackney; George, Barry, Ndiaye |
Palace were the better side for half an hour, and the defending looked as loose as it had in pre-season. Pierre Sage's team were sharper and better organised, with McNeil starting in the No 11 shirt a fortnight after the swap. They hit the woodwork twice. Pickford saved well from Nketiah, and Mateta passed up two clear first-half chances. Moyes did not dress it up afterwards: "At the beginning of the match, Palace looked much more structured and played better than us... With a good deal of luck and a massive amount of effort from the lads, we managed to pull through."
On 42 minutes Harrison Armstrong, the 19-year-old pushed into the side in pre-season, robbed Daniel Muñoz high up the pitch. Dewsbury-Hall bent a left-footed shot in from the edge of the box. Eight minutes into the second half Ndiaye curled in a cross and Barry headed it home, his first Premier League goal of the revenge season he had declared for himself. The forum spent Sunday arguing whether it took a nick off a defender's back on the way in. It went in. Muñoz, the right-back Everton have bid for, was mugged for the opener and rated Palace's worst player at 3/10, "completely off the pace." The scouting, at least, happened live. Palace faded, and Sage did not argue: "in the second half we were with less energy... we gave up a little bit," he said. Chadi Riad was stretchered off with what looked a serious knee injury, his third. The away end and the match thread both wished him well.
Moyes gave the debutants their due. On Hackney: "sometimes boys from the Championship need time, but he's done well". On Armstrong: "he's earning his place in the team... he's shown lots of good things". On the match-winner: "Kiernan showed his growing influence on this team — his finish was outstanding and gave us control." Then, unprompted, he raised the right-back himself: "We definitely would like a right-back before the window closes!" Garner came on in the 79th minute for his first appearance since groin surgery, and almost nobody noticed. Adam Wharton was Palace's best player.
“This kid has class written all over him... comfortable in the end but we could have been a couple down so plenty to work on.”
On Hackney's debut — the fans' forum, saying both things at onceThe match thread ran the course every Evertonian knows. Bullish score predictions before kick-off, nerves inside three minutes, and by the end something close to disbelief at how calm the last twenty minutes felt. Hackney was the discovery of the day. The board compared him to Vitinha and to the great composed debuts of years past, and meant it. Dewsbury-Hall won the forum's man-of-the-match poll comfortably. Röhl at right-back split the room. Some called him a magician, others called him exposed, and a persistent minority wants Röhl in midfield and O'Brien across. The manager's standing moved most. Threads that had spent the week on his tightrope opened on Saturday evening by giving him credit, above all for the nerve of the young selection. The sceptics said the credit is conditional and the first defeat will reopen every argument. The broad middle of the board wants what it saw: this young team kept together and allowed to grow into the league, bad games included. Around the division, Hull beat Manchester United, Spurs lost 3–0 at Brentford and Villa lost 4–0 at Brighton. Across the park, Liverpool opened with a 2–2 at Newcastle, which the blue half records without further comment.
The right-back clock (8 days left): Doue is the forum's theory. Muñoz, Castagne and Cash are the named targets, and Fort is drifting toward Spain or Dortmund. The manager is now asking for one in public. A week ago this looked a squad-building failure wearing a brave face. After one matchday the brave face is winning games. The striker ledger: Barry 1, Beto 0. The forum has long expected Beto to be sold and Delap to arrive, and the press now reports the same. The Moyes temperature: 4.92 out of 10 going in. A win and a bold young XI will lift it, and the poll, not the table, is the measure that matters here. New thread opened: the Armstrong, Hackney and George youth spine, picked sooner than the manager's reputation suggested and taken up at once by the fanbase. Still unresolved: Grealish, Nørgaard's debut, Iroegbunam's limbo.
Deepdale first. The forum has already fought the rotation war to its usual stalemate: the largest camp wants a couple of sensible changes, a purist wing demands the strongest XI and no repeat of the traditional Everton cup surrender, and both sides agree Wednesday is not a night this manager can afford to lose. Then the first away test at Bournemouth, where Marco Rose's side pushed Manchester City close on opening day. That will show whether the young midfield travels, and it may be the last match before deadline day settles the right-back question.
Verified against the primary record before publication: the 2–0 scoreline and goal order (Dewsbury-Hall 42', Barry 53'), attendance 51,820, referee, Everton's 4th place after MW1, all other MW1 results, and the upcoming Preston (26 Aug) and Bournemouth (29 Aug) fixtures. Press record: Goodison News, soccernews.com, Tribal Football, TEAMtalk, Sky Sports. Fan sentiment: peoplesforum.co.uk build-up, match-day and post-match threads, reported at sentiment level (opinion, not fact). Reported, not independently verified: the substitution minutes, Palace's full XI (one source carries a data flaw), the Tarkowski captaincy announcement (single source), the Doue theory (forum-sourced), the Yılmaz €40m verbal offer (Turkish press), and the VAR official. No possession/shots/xG figures were retrievable from any accessible source — none are quoted. The forum thread timeline placed the goals in reverse order; the primary record settles it as reported above.
Second in the series after the season preview (prediction on record: 11th). Season ledger: P1 W1, GF2 GA0 — 4th.
One short message when a new entry is up, usually the night of the match or the morning after. Nothing else, ever. You confirm with one click, and every email carries an unsubscribe link.